This is the worlds leading source of financial content on the web, ranging from market news to retirement strategies, investing education to insights from advisors.
Forex Forever!

Traditional and Roth IRAs: Which is Better for Taxes?

Author: Matthew Jackson

Traditional IRAs and Roth IRAs often are mentioned in the same breath because of their similarities and the advantages they offer. But choosing one over the other without doing further research could end up being a costly decision. Both Traditional and Roth IRAs offer advantages, but those advantages differ and how you choose to invest will depend a lot on your personal financial situation and long-term goals. If you're a bit more aggressive and you want to trade in your Traditional and Roth IRA account(s), there are some other facts you need to know. (For more, see: New Rules for IRA Holders in 2015.)

Traditional IRA

The money contributed to a Traditional IRA is pre-tax. You can trade all you want without any near-term tax consequences, but earnings distributed will be treated as ordinary income when you withdraw your money. Because of Internal Revenue Service rules, you cannot borrow to trade in any type of IRA account. This means no short selling. While you can purchase leveraged and inverse exchange-traded funds to short almost anything, this comes with great risk, and these are tools that should only be used by those with trading experience. The same rule applies to volatility ETFs, which can be even riskier. (For more, see: Can I Buy Mutual Funds for My IRA?)

If you withdraw your money early from a Traditional IRA, you likely will be hit with a 10% tax penalty. The only way to avoid this penalty is if you're using the money for a first-time home purchase, as a qualified education expense, due to death or disability, for unreimbursed medical expenses, or for health insurance if you're unemployed. (For more, see: How Much are Taxes on IRA Withdrawals?)

If you want to avoid that penalty, then you need to wait until you're 59½ years old. You can withdraw without penalty until you're 70½ years old. At that time, you're required to start taking withdrawals, which is referred to as the required minimum distribution, or RMD. Regardless of when you withdraw, any gains will be treated as ordinary income. This will be based on the year you withdraw and the current income tax rate. (For more, see: Six Important Retirement Plan RMD Rules.)

A potential advantage to a Traditional IRA is that contributions may be deductible, depending on tax-filing, active-participant status, and income amount. (For more, see: Traditional IRA Deductibility Limits.)

Roth IRA

With a Roth IRA, you're investing with after-tax dollars. Therefore, there will be no federal income tax on withdrawals. The same trading rules as above apply. Generally, you can stick to stocks, bonds and ETFs without borrowing. (For more, see: Can I Buy ETFs for My Roth IRA?)

Like a Traditional IRA, if you withdraw early, you likely will be hit with a 10% tax penalty. In order to avoid this, your money must have been invested in the Roth IRA for a minimum of five years and you must meet one of the following requirements: 59½ years of age, death or disability, or qualified first-time home purchase. Roth IRA contributions are never deductible, but the tax-free withdrawals are a big advantage. (For more, see: Best Roth IRA Stocks for 2015.)

For both Traditional IRAs and Roth IRAs, the maximum annual investment allowed is $5,500 if you're younger than 50. If you're 50 or older, the maximum annual investment allowed is $6,500. (For more, see: Converting Traditional IRA Savings to a Roth IRA.)

The Bottom Line

Overall, investing in a Roth IRA is likely to have more long-term advantages. That said, this doesn't apply to every investor. Your personal financial situation and long-term investment strategy and goals should play the biggest role in your decision. Of course, it's possible to split your money between a Traditional IRA and a Roth IRA, which is a form of diversification. Please consult your financial advisor prior to making any investment decisions. (For more, see: Roth vs. Traditional IRA: Which is Right for You?)

← back
last five articles

#434 Best Places to Retire: Is Quality of Life Better in a Red State or a Blue State?

Author: Christopher Jackson

For many people facing retirement, the question of how to spend one's golden years is easy to answer. They want to travel the country in an R.V. and fly to far-flung countries abroad. They want quality time spent with children, grandchildren and friends.Whether your retirement bucket list ... see more

#416 5 Reasons Inmates Should Be Taught Financial Literacy

Author: Andrew Harris

Prison education is a well-established factor in preventing relapses. One of the areas in direst need of education is personal finance, as many inmates are unprepared for the outside world upon release. Unfortunately, due to lack of funding, there are few organized efforts in this area beyond cou... see more

#132 How to Hire a Retirement Advisor

Author: Jacob Smith

Possibly the most ignored part of your everyday money life is your retirement. For some, retirement is decades away, so why think about it now? Others feel that they're so far behind on savings that their situation is hopeless. Neither is true. It's never too late to start saving. Equally true: I... see more

#278 Finding The Top Retirement Cities In Malaysia

Author: Daniel Davis

Malaysia's vast tropical jungles are becoming a big tourist draw, but Western expats cluster in its two biggest cities: Kuala Lumpur and George Town, both on the west coast of Peninsular Malaysia. George Town is an island city just across a channel from the mainland. Malaysia's capital city, Kual... see more

#108 Tips for Retirees on How to Use Up Airline Miles (AAL, DAL)

Author: Daniel Davis

You're retired and you've finally got time to travel. Given that you likely have a more limited amount of disposable income than you did when you were working, using frequent flyer miles or points could be the way to go. But miles aren't like cash and first you'll need to do some research – not... see more